Design concept prepared by Hotel Crafted for Chestnut House — not the official website.

A guest house in historic Nantucket Town

Five rooms, a cottage, and a house full of island art.

A lovely old Nantucket home on Chestnut Street, a short walk from Main Street, the Whaling Museum and the island’s finest restaurants. Every room has its own bath and its own story, told through paintings, ceramics and hand-hooked rugs made by the Carl family.

Chestnut House, a shingled Nantucket home with a garden path The carved Chestnut House sign

Stay

Six places to call home on the island.

See dates and rates
Sitting room of Suite 1 with fireplace and Nantucket art

Our largest suite

Suite 1

Street side on the first floor, with a bedroom, a living room with a pull-out sofa, and a private bath with walk-in shower. Room for up to four.

King or twinsSleeps 4298 sq ft
Room 2 with a king bed and hooked rug

Room 2

A cozy second-floor room for two, with a private bath and shower.

King or twinsSleeps 2136 sq ft
Suite 3 bedroom with patchwork quilt

Suite 3

Street side on the second floor, with a sitting room and a walk-in shower.

Queen + sofa bedSleeps 4228 sq ft
Suite 4 bedroom overlooking the garden

Suite 4

At the back of the house, looking over the owner’s garden. Quiet and bright.

King or twinsSleeps 4278 sq ft
Suite 5 sitting room with patterned wallpaper

Suite 5

A second-floor suite at the back, with a sitting room and a bath with tub.

Queen + sofa bedSleeps 4217 sq ft
Willow Cottage kitchen and living area

Willow Cottage

A self-contained cottage with its own entrance and a full kitchen. Ideal for families.

King + wall bedSleeps 4424 sq ft
Jeannette and Jerry Carl surrounded by their arts and crafts

Our story

A home made by hand.

The original owners, Jeannette and Jerry Carl, had backgrounds in fine art and crafts. The house is full of Jeannette’s Nantucket-inspired paintings, drawings, sculpture and ceramics, and Jerry’s hooked rugs, each one designed and made by him.

Their spirit is still in every room, and being able to talk with our guests is what we enjoy most.

Returning guests often ask for “their” room: the one with the iris mural, or the daffodils.

The little extras

A library, and one last shower before the ferry.

Our library is yours: beach reads, children’s books and a shelf on the history of the island. After check-out, it’s a quiet place to wait for your ferry, and we keep a spare bathroom with shower so you can enjoy your last day on the beach.

Arriving early? We’ll happily store your luggage.

The guest library at Chestnut House

Location

In the heart of Town. Leave the car behind.

Chestnut House sits in the core historic district. Everything you came for is a short walk away.

  • Main StreetShops, galleries and restaurants
  • Whaling MuseumThe island’s early history
  • Visitor CenterIsland tours, just down the street
  • Bike & moped rentalsFor the beaches out of town
Hand-drawn map showing Chestnut House near Main Street

Good to know

Simple, friendly policies.

Check-in 3 pm · Check-out 11 amWe’ll store your bags if you arrive early or leave late.
In every roomPrivate bath, air conditioning, TV, mini-fridge and Wi-Fi.
A peaceful houseNon-smoking, and sorry, no pets. Open all year.

Come stay with us on Chestnut Street.

Book online in a minute, or call Ian. He loves helping guests plan their time on the island.

Check availability Call